Hard water spots come from hard water drops when they evaporate. Hard water comes from the ground (sprinkers or the garden hose), and concrete/brick efflorescence. It is called "hard" because of the total dissolved solids (TDS). The key word being solids. Basically these solids are microscopic pieces of rock or minerals. So another name for hard water spots is mineral deposits. When the water poofs away in the hot sun, these little pieces of rock are left behind. Most of the time they are based on a silicate chemistry. This is a silicon molecule that includes the elements oxygen and some metal (calcium, sodium, magnesium, etc.). Window glass is based on a silica/silicate matrix. Silica is silicon and oxygen only. Most of the silicates in glass are based on calcium and sodium. Since the chemistry of most hard water spots is very similar to that of window glass, they usually form a good bond. Another reason they bond well is size. These little pieces of rock are around two to five microns across most of the time. Also the microscopic pores of window glass are about five microns. So these mineral particles "fit" very well into the micropores of glass surfaces. And there they stick! As we know all too well.
Most if not all of the hard water spot removal products on the commercial market are based on acids and or abrasives. The idea is to either chemically eat up these little pieces of rock, or abrade them away physically;...or both at the same time. I've always been in favor of the very last option. If the spots are based mostly on a silicate chemistry, then the only acids that will eat them up are those that will eat up the surface of the window glass. Here I am talking about mineral acids. So called because they are not based on a carbon chemistry like glyconic acid. Some common mineral acids that work good at dissolving mineral deposits based on silicates, and etching glass surfaces;... are hydrofluoric, sulfuric, and ammoniumbifluoride. If the spots are based almost entirely on calcium carbonate or sodium carbonate;... mild acids like sulfamic, acetic, citric, or glycolic will work well. Then if you add a polishing powder such as an optical grade silica, cerium oxide, or aluminum oxide;...you will have the best of both worlds for a real quick fix. I never advise the use of mineral acids which are glass etchants. If the spots are based almost entirely on silicates, then the only way to deal with them effectively and safely is by means of a refined optical grade polishing compound or slurry. Any milder organic acids at this point are a simple waste of time and money. A few quick tests will determine in a matter of minutes exactly what the nature of the problem is.
Now while there are many different hard water spot removal products out there on the commercial market, I strongly urge extreme caution. Many of the manufacturers of these products have little knowledge of the technical nature of the problem;... along with the products and techniques necessary to safely and effectively solve it. Education is critical. Anyone performing glass restoration needs to be completely educated. Otherwise they could waste entire buildings, and bring on themselves tremendous lawsuits. I have been called in to consult on several such. This kind of education is one of the reasons I have established this blog. There will be more articles on hard water spot removal techniques posted here in coming days.
Henry Grover Jr.
Glass Tech Consulting
gtcnews@hotmail.com